News

1 / 3 / 2015

Northern Ireland Soroptimists hold Cross Border Conference on Human Trafficking

Cross border forced labour conference 21 January 2015

Dromantine Conference Centre, Newry

Overview

This event was the second cross border conference on human trafficking, with a specific emphasis on responding to forced labour. The conference was opened by Minister of Justice, David Ford, and Minister of State at the Department of Justice and Equality, Aodhán Ó’Ríordán. A number of experts gave presentations throughout the day, before sitting on a panel for a Q&A session to close the conference.

Presentations

• Neil Jarman from the Institute for Conflict Research spoke about the emergence of the problem of forced labour in Northern Ireland, the scale of the problem and recent developments. He then referred to:
• recognition of the problem – initially discovered in Northern Ireland amongst Lithuanians in the mushroom picking industry in 2002;
• response to the problem – legislative and policy response, awareness raising, and recognition of the problem by some employers; and
• the challenges faced when tackling it – lack of understanding of the scale, lack of prosecutions, and lack of good engagement with business.

• Grainne O’Toole from Migrant Rights Centre Ireland then set the scene in the Republic of Ireland. She explained the background and role of MRCI and outlined the work they have done with victims of forced labour. She also highlighted the key challenges faced in successfully identifying victims. These included:
• The level of threat and control used by perpetrators;
• The techniques of perpetrators becoming increasingly sophisticated; and
• Flaws within the current model of identification.

Ms O’ Toole was accompanied by Mariaam Bhatti, who gave a personal account of her experience of forced labour in Ireland.

• Paul Broadbent, Chief Executive of the Gangmasters Licensing Authority (GLA) then outlined the work of GLA, including its involvement in a Police Scotland case, which had included two victims of labour exploitation and human trafficking in Northern Ireland. He explained how a number of relevant agencies had worked together, across borders, to investigate this case, and to provide support and assistance to the victims.

• John Kelly of the National Employment Rights Authority (NERA) outlined the role of and structures within NERA. He outlined the main breaches of employment law which they encountered, NERA’s role in identification and disruption and forthcoming legislative changes in the south which would assist NERA in combating exploitation.

• Kevin Hyland, UK Independent Anti Slavery Commissioner then outlined his vision of the role and responsibilities of his newly established office. He highlighted the importance of international work with countries of origin, in trying to stop trafficking at the source. He recognised the unique position that Northern Ireland is in with the shared land border, and how this can be, and has been, exploited by traffickers. He also referred to the disparity between the assessed number of victims and the reported figures for this type of crime, and his desire to address this discrepancy. His presentation was the culmination of a three day visit to Northern Ireland, during which he met with a number of stakeholders and NGOs.

Feedback from Workshops

There were six workshops focussing on three themes: Challenges for law enforcement; Prevention and identification; and awareness and training.  The key findings from the discussions are set out below.

Challenges for law enforcement

These workshops were asked to consider the main challenges and obstacles faced when investigating forced labour, including specific cross border issues; and action that could be taken to make the investigative process easier or more effective.

Issues and challenges

There were a range of issues that made both the investigative and prosecution processes difficult.

–          Primarily, victims did not want to cooperate with the authorities through fear and getting the trust and support of the victim is an issue.

–          Some victims want to return home immediately after they are recovered and as a result contact is lost.

–          Others do not recognise themselves as victims of exploitation and considered their exploited situation better than life in their home country.

–          Even if victims are cooperative, the process is a lengthy one and support could dwindle over the course of time.

There are practical challenges for the police and prosecution services.

–          It is difficult to ascertain the tipping point between labour exploitation and forced labour.

–          The identification of victims at crime scenes is also an issue – are they victims or suspects?  In RoI, is An Garda Síochána’s role in identifying victims in the National Referral Mechanism appropriate or should the criminal investigation and identification of victims be separated?

–          Getting evidence that is admissible and that meets the “beyond reasonable doubt” threshold for a criminal conviction is a key part of the process.

Specific cross border issues include:

–          the different legislative frameworks and information sharing protocols;

–          the difficulty in monitoring individuals as they cross the border; and

–          the challenges presented by victims living on one side of the border but working on the other.

Actions

A number of actions were suggested:

–          Keep victims   up-to-date with criminal proceedings by maintaining contact throughout the course of the process;

–          Ensure that victims  are  provided with appropriate support (financial or otherwise) as proceedings progress;

–          Look to enhancing information sharing between statutory agencies (north and south) and with non statutory organisations working with victims or potential victims;

–          Use information provided by victims to trigger wider investigations;

–          Maintain joint training between AGS and PSNI;

–          Seek to run Joint Investigation Teams (JITs) wherever possible and make use of Eurojust (EU Judicial Cooperation office);

–          Assess which country is best to prosecute in;

–          Use innovative means to increase chances of prosecution.  For example, in Germany diaries of victims’ experiences had been used in court to support prosecutions (this was a trade union initiative).  Placing on obligation on employers to prove payments to workers;

–          Work towards a pan European understanding by law enforcement of human trafficking for forced labour.

–          Sanctions against companies found to engage in forced labour practices such as ineligibility for government contracts.

–          Collecting objective evidence e.g. obliging employers to demonstrate payments.

Prevention and identification

These workshops considered the key stakeholders, both statutory and non statutory, that might come into contact with victims of forced labour.  Engaging these stakeholders; protecting and upholding victims’ rights; and specific cross border challenges to prevention and identification were also discussed.

Stakeholders

Attendees identified a wide range of stakeholders in government and civil society, including individuals working in:

–          the health and education sector, such as teachers and doctors;

–          jobs and benefits offices;

–          housing authorities;

–          local government, such as health and safety officers and those with licensing roles;

–          tax authorities;

–          organisations with an employment inspectorate function, including NERA and the Employment Agency Inspectorate;

–          government subcontractors;

–          any public sector workers with an inspection function;

–          migrant support groups;

–          community and youth workers;

–          landlords;

–          taxi companies;

–          employers in key sectors (eg. agricultural, meat processing etc)

Whilst there are a significant number of stakeholders, not all of them want to be engaged on forced labour; some delegates suggested that a number of key influencers might at times display a tolerance of it.  It is important to separate the victim from the crime and challenge the assumption that victims of forced labour are complicit in criminality or are always foreign nationals.

Empowering potential victims

There is also the issue of people who do not recognise themselves as having been exploited, sometimes because of different cultural norms in their home countries.

–          Migrants should be educated about their employment rights in Ireland and be able to assert them – although having the confidence to do so could take some time.

–          Helping victims to protect and uphold their rights needs a creative approach.  Many cannot read or write so visual awareness raising, through TV and posters, would be useful.

–          Word of mouth, particularly through community groups, could play an important role.

–          Early intervention models could prevent people from getting caught up in exploitative situations in the first place.

Business

As well as general awareness raising, there needs to be specific focus on the business community.

–          Emphasising the potential reputational damage and financial loss, whilst revealing the human cost of exploitation, could help persuade businesses to cooperate.

–          This should be coupled with “upstream” education in countries of origin.

Awareness and training

These workshops considered the level of awareness of forced labour; the approaches to be taken in raising awareness of the crime; and training for both statutory bodies and NGOs.

The level of awareness of forced labour across Ireland was considered quite low, although things are beginning to change.

–          Data is a key factor:  statistics and information should be made widely available to inform debate and understanding of this form of exploitation.

Identifying “at risk” factors

In understanding and raising awareness of forced labour, people needed to take a broader view: whilst immigration status or language skills are factors contributing to vulnerability, forced labour was not primarily an issue of race or limited to migrant workers.

–          For example, education in schools could look at how migrants are viewed in the community;

–          There was a need to understand forced labour in a human context, rather than a migrant context.

–          Other key vulnerabilities not linked to migrant status, such as alcoholism, poverty or mental health problems, could leave people more at risk of exploitation.

–          Unregulated, part-time, seasonal and mobile work

Engaging consumers and businesses

The general public should be made aware that its behaviour could encourage forced labour.

–          Forced labour is driven by the demand for cheap goods and as such there is a real need for responsible consumerism.

–          Business has a moral duty to operate ethically and free workshops for those in relevant industries could draw attention to forms of exploitation within supply chains; the benefits of knowing suppliers; and provide advice on how to respond.

–          Furthermore, awareness raising should be targeted around known trafficking routes and at entry points such as ports and airports.

–          Really ‘hard to reach’ communities could be approached, for example, by church groups and made aware of their rights as early as possible.

–          Campaign to encourage workers to maintain a diary.

Training

–          It was suggested that industry standards for anti trafficking actors should be adopted.  These should be flexible enough to capture new trends and respond to emerging forms of exploitation.

–          Language used in training should be easy to understand and technical terms used only within certain fields or occupations should be avoided. 

Conclusion

The conference was well attended by individuals from both statutory and non governmental backgrounds, with a number of new stakeholders engaging on this topic for the first time.

The discussions will help to inform the work of the Department of Justice and the Department of Justice and Equality in tackling forced labour and in particular, raising awareness of this crime.

Initial feedback has been very positive, however attendees will be invited to provide more detailed feedback to determine which aspects of the day were most useful, and if anything further should have been covered.

8 / 2 / 2015

Congratulations SI Cambridge

Well done Cambridge Soroptimists who have partnered with Cambridge City Council to put Purple Teardrop Campaign awareness posters into public wcs throughout the city.

8 / 2 / 2015

Day for Victims of Human Trafficking and those who Work to Combat it

Today, 8th February is the Day for Victims of Human Trafficking and those who work to combat it. A Vatican initiative, the prayers and thoughts of Catholics around the globe turn to human trafficking.

Pope Francis is working tirelessly on human trafficking through the Santa Marta group which is composed of High Commissioners of international police forces and bishops from around the world who, along with members of civil society, are working together to prevent and eradicate human trafficking, and to help victims. Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe, Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis, London, and Cardinal Nichols are the co-presidents of the group.

31 / 1 / 2015

Medaille Trust Concert for Human Trafficking Victims

The Medaille Trust is hosting a charity band concert for victims of human trafficking.

Saturday, 7th February 2015, 7pm
Salvation Army
70 Baddow Road
Chelmsford
CM2 0DD

This is a free event but there will be a collection if you wish to make a donation. There will also be the opportunity to purchase hand-crafted items made by women at Mama Margaret’s Project in Kenya.

More information

31 / 1 / 2015

Latest Lobby Progress Report

Thank you to everyone who has signed up to our ‘ban sex for sale adverts’ lobby over the past couple of months. We’re very nearly up to 34,000 signatures. With your help, we can get to 36,000 by International Women’s Day on 8th March!

Latest Progress Report

Latest Bar Chart by Postcode

Information on our Lobby

3 / 1 / 2015

Santa Marta Group Press Release

PRESS RELEASE

For immediate release – 3 December

 Police and Church partner to combat human trafficking

Taking the lead on human trafficking: second international conference of the Santa Marta Group, London 5-6 December.

Police chiefs and Church representatives from across the world are coming to London to join Home Office ministers for a Conference aimed at developing strategies to combat human trafficking. The guiding principle of the Santa Marta Group is always to keep the welfare of the trafficked victim at the heart of all law enforcement.

The conference, which will take place in London on 5-6 December, is being organised by the Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales, the Metropolitan Police Service (MPS) and the Home Office. The delegates are coming at the invitation of Cardinal Vincent Nichols, Archbishop of Westminster, and MPS Commissioner Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe. The conference has been organised with the full support of the Home Office, which is hosting the event at Lancaster House, and will be addressed by the Home Secretary Theresa May, and the Minister for Modern Slavery and Organised Crime, Karen Bradley.

At the launch of the Santa Marta Group, named after the Papal residence where the participants stayed, in April 2014 Pope Francis described human trafficking as “an open wound on the body of contemporary society; a crime against humanity”.

The Santa Marta Group, led by Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe and Cardinal Nichols is an alliance of international police chiefs and Bishops from around the world, working together with civil society to eradicate human trafficking and provide pastoral care to victims. It seeks to develop strategies in prevention, pastoral care and re-integration by working together internationally.

At its launch, the police chiefs signed a declaration of commitment in which they stated: “As senior law enforcement officials within the international community, we commit to eradicate the scourge of this serious criminal activity, which abuses vulnerable people.” The full text is available below.

The conference at Lancaster House will also showcase and build on the joint police and church initiative in London that has been running for the past three years; a collaboration that is to be copied and adapted around the world.

Training modules and good practice will be shared and developed. Closer collaboration will also enable joint investigations between law enforcement agencies enabling a more co-ordinated international approach to rid the world from the scourge of the world’s second most profitable crime: estimated by the International Labour Organisation to generate $32bn annual profits for criminals, with 2.4 million people trafficked globally at any given time.

Home Secretary Theresa May said:

“I am delighted to be hosting the Santa Marta Conference, a forum dedicated to the eradication of Modern Slavery which brings together police chiefs and bishops from across the globe.

“This government has taken great strides to tackle this abhorrent crime.  The publication of the Modern Slavery Bill is the first of its kind in Europe and gives law enforcement the tools they need to target slave drivers, ensuring their prosecution as well as the protection of their victims.

“But this is a problem that cannot be addressed through legislation alone.  It requires action at all levels of society.   That is why, last week, we published the Modern Slavery Strategy which makes it clear we must work together to tackle exploitation both here and overseas.”

Cardinal Nichols said:

“The Santa Marta Group is not about theory; it is focused on rescuing people who have become victims of trafficking and find themselves in an impossible situation.

“This week we meet again in London to continue this important collaboration between Church, police, government and civil society, reporting on the progress made this year and planning future area of work. Since April, The Church has launched the Bakhita Initiative, comprising a refuge for victims and a hub where good practice on prevention, pastoral care and reintegration will be developed and disseminated nationally and internationally, in addition to the ongoing work of the Santa Marta Group.

“The work against trafficking lies at the heart of the Church’s pastoral concern and ministry. There is much to be done, but the emergence of the Santa Marta Group’s international network is an important step towards helping the victims and fighting this crime.”

Metropolitan Police Service Commissioner, Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe said:

“I am proud that London is hosting the second Santa Marta Conference. It allows us to highlight human trafficking on an international platform and demonstrate the determination of church leaders, communities and our policing colleagues worldwide to combat these horrendous crimes.

“Knowing the full scale of the problem is an almost impossible task as those most vulnerable to exploitation often live at the margins of our society and the criminals hide in the shadows.

“However, this must not stop those who can help, from all nations, making the commitment to do everything they can to enable trafficking victims to escape the clutches of their captors and bring the criminals involved to justice.

“We know our collective efforts are not adequate to end this modern form of slavery and therefore we must all do more.”

ENDs

For further information on the Santa Marta Group, the conference and interview requests for Cardinal Nichols contact Alexander DesForges 07983 704 09707983 704 097 alexander.desforges@cbcew.org.uk

For interview requests for the Minister for Modern Slavery and Organised Crime on Friday 5 December, ahead of the conference, please contact Marie Hagen at the Home Office press office on 0207 035 38390207 035 3839marie.hagen@homeoffice.gsi.gov.uk

Acting Detective Chief Inspector Phil Brewer from the MPS Trafficking and Kidnap Unit and Detective Sergeant Phil Rashidi from the MPS Victim Referral Team are available for interviews on Thursday 4 December, between 9am-midday.  Please register your interest with the MPS Specialist Crime and Operations Press Desk by emailing DMC-COP@met.police.uk or contacting the press bureau on 0207 230 21710207 230 2171.

16 / 12 / 2014

SI Barnstaple Taxi Success

Barnstaple Soroptimists have received permission for Purple Teardrop Campaign leaflets to be provided to taxi drivers applying for and renewing their Hackney Carriage license.

SI Barnstaple has worked with their local MP, the police and the Safer North Devon group to achieve this.

16 / 12 / 2014

Inspirational work by SI Paisley

Purple Teardrop Campaign / Love Me/Love Me Not Bookmarks and Credit Cards.

SI Paisley ordered 2,000 bookmarks  with the Scottish Domestic Abuse Helpline number on them, and 600 credit cards which had labels with the Scottish Helpline number added to them.

The following groups were given cards/bookmarks:

STAR project (local women’s support group) 100  cards / 100 bookmarks

Renfrewshire Women’s Association for AGM

Reclaim the Night goody bags 250 bookmarks

Renfrewshire Council 100 bookmarks

Local libraries  500 bookmarks

Women’s Aid 100 cards / 100 bookmarks

Women and Children First 100 cards / 100 bookmarks

Glasgow Airport Police 50 cards / 150 bookmarks

More will be distributed as appropriate.

SI Paisley supported Renfrewshire’s first ever Reclaim the Night walk on Monday 25 November. Members provided support as marshalls on the walk, and manned a stall at Paisley Town Hall to promote Soroptimism, the Purple Teardrop Campaign and Human Trafficking and collected a small number of signatures for the ban sex for sale advertising petition.

The first picture includes five Paisley Soroptimists with the Provost and the second picture shows SI Paisley’s President on the left.

4 / 12 / 2014

Latest Lobby News

Our Ban Sex for Sale Advertising lobby is now one third of the way to its 100,000 signatures target. Many thanks to the Soroptimist Clubs and supporters who sent in over 1,000 signatures in October. With your help, we can make it to 35,000 signatures by the end of 2014. For more details plus a round-up of the wonderful Soroptimist support during Anti Slavery Week, please see our latest Progress Report.

4 / 12 / 2014

Soroptimist International, 16 Days of Activism against Gender Violence

16 Days – Day Eight: Human Trafficking

02/12/14